Triple Cheese Sourdough Grilled Cheese

The kitchen was dark except for the stove light when I first experimented with the triple cheese combination. I was hosting a late night movie marathon and needed something that felt special but could come together in twenty minutes. That first batch had cheese everywhere, but the way provolone pulled against sharp cheddar made my friends pause the movie. Now this is the sandwich I make when comfort food needs to feel like a real meal instead of just a quick fix.

My roommate walked in during one of my testing phases and asked why I was so particular about sourdough thickness. I explained that thin slices get soggy while thick ones hold up against all that melting cheese. She took one bite of the finished sandwich and immediately asked for the recipe. That afternoon we sat on the kitchen floor eating grilled cheese straight from the cutting board and decided some meals are worth the extra prep.

Ingredients

• Thick sourdough bread: The substantial texture supports the heavy cheese filling without getting soggy or floppy
• Sharp cheddar cheese: Provides the bold punch that cuts through the richness of the other cheeses
• Provolone cheese: Adds a mild creamy element and creates those gorgeous cheese pulls
• Shredded mozzarella cheese: Acts as the melting glue that holds everything together
• Unsalted butter: Spreads evenly and creates that classic buttery crunch on the exterior
• Mayonnaise: The secret ingredient for achieving restaurant level crispiness and golden color

Instructions

Prep your bread:

Spread softened butter on one side of each sourdough slice and mayo on the other if using

Build the layers:

Place cheddar and provolone slices on the unbuttered side then sprinkle with shredded mozzarella

Assemble sandwiches:

Top with remaining slices buttered side up creating a neat package ready for the heat

Start cooking:

Place sandwiches in your heated skillet buttered side down and let them sizzle gently

Flip carefully:

Cook until golden then turn and press slightly to help the cheese meld together completely

Rest and serve:

Let them sit for one minute before cutting to keep all that melted cheese inside

Save to Pinterest

This recipe became my go to after my daughter declared it better than any diner version she had ever tried. Now she requests it whenever she has a rough day at school and I know exactly what that means. Something about the combination of crunch and three kinds of melting cheese just makes everything feel better.

Making It Your Own

The beauty of this sandwich is how well it adapts to whatever cheese you have in the fridge. I have used Gruyere when feeling fancy and pepper jack when craving some heat. Each variation brings something slightly different but the method stays the same.

The Perfect Soup Pairing

Tomato soup is the classic partner but do not overlook other options. A butternut squash soup brings sweetness that balances the sharp cheddar beautifully. Even a simple bowl of chicken noodle soup feels complete next to this sandwich.

Getting That Restaurant Crunch

The butter and mayonnaise technique changed everything about my grilled cheese game. I resisted it for years thinking it was unnecessary but one try convinced me completely. The oil in mayonnaise has a higher smoke point than butter alone so the bread gets extra crispy without burning.

• Use room temperature ingredients for even spreading
• Let the pan heat up fully before adding sandwiches
• A cast iron skillet holds heat most evenly

Save to Pinterest

Some recipes are just meant to be simple and this one proves that three cheeses and good bread are all you really need.

Frequently Asked Recipe Questions

→ What type of cheddar works best?

Sharp or extra-sharp cheddar provides the most flavor and complexity. Aged cheddars have a more pronounced taste that stands up well against the milder provolone and mozzarella.

→ Can I use different cheeses?

Absolutely. Swiss, Gruyère, fontina, or any melting cheese works well. Stick to cheeses that melt smoothly and avoid hard varieties like Parmesan for the main layers.

→ Why cook on medium-low heat?

Medium-low heat gives the cheese time to melt completely while the bread toasts gently. High heat burns the exterior before the interior melts, resulting in uneven cooking.

→ Should I press the sandwich while cooking?

Yes, gently press with a spatula during cooking to ensure even contact with the skillet and help the cheese melt uniformly throughout.

→ What makes the bread extra crispy?

A thin layer of mayonnaise on the inside adds moisture that paradoxically creates crispness. The butter on the outside is essential—don't skip it for golden, crunchy bread.

→ Can I make this ahead of time?

Assemble the sandwich and refrigerate up to 4 hours before cooking. It may take 1–2 minutes longer to cook from cold, so adjust timing accordingly.